Capitalism was born in england, yet the dominant western conceptions of modernity have come from elsewhere, notably from france, the historical model of bourgeois society. In the first part of the article, i present wood s thesis concerning the historical origin of capitalism and its political implications. Does david roediger disagree with ellen meiksins wood. Ellen meiksins wood york university, toronto abstract this article challenges the currently fashionable periodization of history since the eighteenth century into two major phases, modernity and postmodernity. Ellen meiksins wood there was a time, not very long ago, when one of the most serious and frequent criticisms levelled against marxism was that it subscribed to a mechanical and simplistic view of history according to which all societies were predestined to go through a single, inexorable sequence of. Download ellen meiksins wood democracia contra capitalismo. A longer view 2002 its a brilliant book, a marxist account highly sympathetic to robert.
In this original and provocative book ellen meiksins wood reminds us that capitalism is not a natural and inevitable consequence of human nature, nor is it simply an extension of ageold practices of trade and commerce. In this original and provocative book ellen meiksins wood reminds us that capitalism is not a. In this clarifying work, ellen meiksins wood refutes most existing accounts of the origin of capitalism, which, she argues, fail to recognize capitalism s distinctive attributes as a social system, making it seem a culmination of a natural human inclination. Meiksins wood hereafter emw exhorts us, thinking about future alternatives to capitalism requires us. Democracy against capitalism download ebook pdf, epub. Ellen meiksins wood showed so many of us what it means to be a committed intellectual. Ellen meiksins wood frsc april 12, 1942 january 14, 2016 was an americancanadian marxist historian and scholar biography.
Following meiksins wood s own approach to political theory, we consider her work about the contradictory relationship between capitalism and. Current intellectual fashions of the left which emphasize postmodern fragmentation, difference, contingency and the politics of. Capitalism the economic and the political in capitalism classpower and statepower feudalism and private property capitalism as the privatisation of political power the localisation of classstruggle england vs. Ellen meiksins wood argues that, with the collapse of com munism, the theoretical project of marxism and its critique of capitalism is more timely and important. Capitalism is not a natural and inevitable consequence of human nature, nor is it simply an extension of ageold practices of trade and commerce. Ellen meiksins wood passed away yesterday after a long struggle with cancer. Ellen meiksins wood critiques accounts about the origin of capitalism across the political spectrum, including marxistsfor overlooking the begging questions about what really drove the emergence of capitalism. A social history of western political thought from the renaissance to enlightenment ebook. Rather, it is a late and localized product of very specific historical conditions, which required great transformations in. Publication date 1991 topics capitalism history, capitalism great britain history, political science history, great britain politics and government publisher. So this tool was designed for free download documents from the internet. In the origin of capitalism, a nowclassic work of history, ellen meiksins wood offers readers a clear and accessible introduction to the theories and debates. All these things, taken together, are commonly taken to be synonymous with capitalism.
Historian and political thinker ellen meiksins wood argues that theories of postmodern fragmentation, difference, and contingency. Ellen meiksins wood 19422016, for many years professor of political science at york university, toronto, was the author of many books, including democracy against capitalism, the pristine culture of capitalism, the origin of capitalism, peasantcitizen and slave, citizens to lords, empire of capital and liberty and property. This acclaimed book by ellen meiksins wood is available at in several formats for your ereader. It is precisely this identification that is challenged in this essay by marxist historian ellen meiksins wood, along with the notion that ascribing european agrarian origins to capitalism entails a view of europe as a. How did the dynamic economic system we know as capitalism develop among the peasants and lords of feudal europe. The origins of capitalism according to ellen meiksins wood. Wood was born in new york city as ellen meiksins one year after her parents, latvian jews active in the bund, arrived in new york from europe as political refugees. Ellen meiksins wood, for many years professor of political science at york university, toronto, was the author of many books, including democracy against capitalism, the pristine culture of capitalism, the origin of capitalism, peasantcitizen and slave, citizens to lords, empire of capital and liberty and property. Current intellectual fashions of the left which emphasise postmodern fragmentation, difference, contingency and the politics of identity can barely accommodate the idea. In the autumn of 1980, thierry paquot invited me to write a short book for a series he was editing in paris. Second, in the actuality of history, race has not been separable from the economic logic of capital in the way that is. Wood was an extraordinarily rigorous and imaginative thinker, someone who breathed life into marxist political theory and made it speaknot to just to me but to many othersat multiple levels.
Questioning the conception of modernity itself, wood. Ellen meiksins wood, for many years professor of political science at york university, toronto, was the author of many books, including democracy against capitalism, the pristine culture of capitalism, the origin of capitalism, peasantcitizen and slave, citizens. Ellen meiksins wood professor emerita of political science. Ellen meiksins wood quotes author of the origin of. Symposium on ellen meiksins woods empire of capital. Few questions of history have as many contemporary political implications as this deceptively simple one. In part ii, wood argues that capitalism emerged in the unique conditions of late medieval and early modern english agrarian society, basing her argument firmly on robert brenners agrarian class structure and economic development in preindustrial europe. About us we believe everything in the internet must be free. Capitalism is supposed to have been born and bred in the city. In the first edition, i thanked neal wood for his comments and. Ellen meiksins wood argues that with the collapse of communism the theoretical project of marxism and its critique of capitalism is more timely and important than ever. Pdf on oct 1, 2002, ricardo duchesne and others published on the origins of capitalism find, read and cite all the research you need on researchgate. Ellen meiksins wood, for many years professor of political science at york university, toronto, is the author of many books, including the pristine culture of capitalism, the origin of capitalism, peasantcitizen and slave, citizens to lords, empire of capital and liberty and property. Democracy against capitalism by ellen meiksins wood.
This article represents a critical reading of ellen meiksins wood s book the origin of capitalism. The ellen meiksins wood reader edited by larry patriquin. Ellen meiksins wood, for many years professor of political science at york university, toronto, is the author of many books, including democracy against capitalism and, with verso, the pristine culture of capitalism, the origin of capitalism, peasantcitizen and slave, citizens to lords, empire of capital and liberty and property. Ellen meiksins wood in this original and provocative book ellen meiksins wood reminds us that capitalism is not a natural and inevitable consequence of human nature, nor is it simply an extension of ageold practices. Ellen meiksins wood custom against capitalism the appeal to history in the justification of capitalism has always required a delicate balancing act. Ellen meiksins wood 19422016, for many years professor of political science at york university, toronto, was the author of many books, including democracy against capitalism, the pristine culture of capitalism, the origin of capitalism, peasant citizen and slave, citizens to lords, empire of capital and liberty and property. The pristine culture of capitalism, and democracy against capitalism. Reposted from rosaluxemburgstiftung without german translation to improve the flow and listenability of the english portion. A critique of ellen meiksins wood s empire of capital. Review of the origins of capitalism, by ellen meiksins wood. The untimely death of ellen meiksins wood on january 14, 2016 deprived the left of one of its most original voices. Ellen meiksins wood argues that, with the collapse of communism, the theoretical project of marxism and its critique of capitalism is more timely and important than ever.
Ellen meiksins wood democracy against capitalism marx 200. In this original and provocative book ellen meiksins wood reminds us that capitalism is not a natural and inevitable consequence of human nature. This globalisation lecture entitled the imperial paradox. The origin of capitalism the damage, as many millions of people have often suffered from the cure as from the disease. The origin of capitalism is a 1999 book on history and political economy, specifically the history of capitalism, by scholar ellen meiksins wood, written from the. This book had its immediate origin in two successive requests. Capitalism is also incapable of promoting sustainable development, not because it encourages technological advances that are capable of straining the earths resources but because the purpose of capitalist production is exchange value not use value, profit not people. The increasingly transparent weaknesses and contradictions in the capitalist system may eventually convince even some of its more uncritical supporters that an alternative needs to be found. As many readers will know, karl marx wrote these words, but used bourgeoisie instead of capitalism. The death of ellen wood on january 14 represents an immense loss for socialists everywhere. The increasingly transparent weaknesses and contradictions in the capitalist system may eventually convince even some of its more uncritical supporters that an. As a frequent contributor to socialist register since her first essay in 1980, special coeditor of the 1995 volume why not capitalism, and a member of the registers editorial collective from 1996 to 2009, her depth of socialist commitment, theoretical originality, and profound insight may best be. Capitalism as the privatisation of political power. The pitfalls of realist analysis of global capitalism.
Wood was a thinker of extraordinary range, writing with authority on ancient greece, early modern political thought, contemporary political theory, marxism, and the structure and evolution of modern capitalism. The words were swapped in a 2012 lecture by john lanchester he of whoops, and capital marking marxs 193rd birthday, to show how prescient he was in describing the structure of capitalism and the way in which it changes the landscape. The origin of capitalism is a 1999 book on history and political economy by scholar ellen meiksins wood. Ellen meiksins wooddemocracy against capitalism no. These findings directly challenge woods contention that brenners thesis is firmly. Ellen meiksins wood back in the mid1990s, when i was first getting a handle on the academic left, wood s articles on postmodernism were very useful to me. Download wood, ellen meiksins a origem do capitalismo. On the one hand, we are obliged to accept that capitalist modernization thoroughly transformed the world to the unambiguous benefit of. Historian and political thinker ellen meiksins wood argues that theories of postmodern fragmentation, difference, and contingency can barely accommodate the idea of capitalism, let alone subject it to critique. The origin of capitalism assume the very thing that needs to be explained. Pdf the origins of capitalism according to ellen meiksins wood.
692 82 345 705 425 591 46 1193 372 786 1108 777 688 247 1486 815 984 1045 445 1067 1258 1486 1321 403 1325 232 1251 351 221 1378 725 647 1402 1085 586